According to Reason's Volokh Conspiracy, which excerpted the ruling, Judge Allison Burroughs of the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts found in Lattarulo v. Mullin that an immigration lawyer was likely to succeed on a First Amendment retaliation claim. Customs and Border Protection agents and a Homeland Security Investigations officer stopped the lawyer at Logan Airport on September 28, 2025, seized his phone without a warrant and copied its data. The phone was returned eight days later. The judge wrote that the search was highly unusual, came early in an HSI employment investigation of his law firm, and was not applied to his partner, who had returned a day earlier. She enjoined defendants from accessing the data while the case proceeds. The government said it has additional evidence but withheld it to protect an ongoing investigation, and said a taint team would protect privileged material. The court did not decide the Fourth Amendment claim.
Why it matters
The ruling is a preliminary finding that a warrantless device search at the border may have been retaliation for protected speech. The phone holds privileged attorney-client communications, and the court left open whether the border search exception covers a domestic employment investigation.
These are unproven claims, and everyone named is presumed innocent unless proven guilty. Researched with AI assistance from the sources listed here and reviewed under our methodology.
Dont Comply