AllegedOverreach

Forest Service Officers Tell Wyoming Llama Outfitter Appearing in Monetized Videos Violates Wilderness Act; He Sues

Reason reports that Forest Service law enforcement officers told a Wyoming llama outfitter that appearing in a monetized video without a commercial film permit is illegal, prompting a federal lawsuit challenging the policy.

According to Reason, two uniformed U.S. Forest Service law enforcement officers met Wyoming llama outfitter Josh Smunk about a Yellowstone permit and told him a September 2025 vodcast he appeared in, filmed in Shoshone National Forest, violated federal law because it lacked a commercial film permit. Reason reports he was told he could face up to a year in prison, a $100,000 fine and a ban from public lands, and that his personal Instagram videos were also prohibited. He was not charged. A Forest Service employee wrote in a follow-up email reviewed by Reason that people who monetize wilderness filming 'through clicks' are pursued. Smunk and the BlueRibbon Coalition have filed a federal lawsuit, which argues the policy exceeds the Wilderness Act and burdens First Amendment expression. Reason does not report a Forest Service response. Smunk says officials told him only one commercial film permit has been granted in 25 years.

Why it matters

The lawsuit argues the Forest Service's reading of the Wilderness Act could reach anyone who posts monetized video from wilderness areas and could restrict First Amendment expression. The claims are the plaintiffs' allegations and have not been decided by a court.

These are unproven claims, and everyone named is presumed innocent unless proven guilty. Researched with AI assistance from the sources listed here and reviewed under our methodology.