Courthouse News reports that victims' families and district attorneys, represented by the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, filed suit at the California Supreme Court over Gov. Gavin Newsom's Nov. 5 commutation of all 548 death sentences to life without parole. The plaintiffs allege Newsom failed to give district attorneys and victims the notice and opportunity to be heard that they say the law requires, did not conduct individual reviews, and did not follow the process for people with multiple felony convictions, which they say requires a recommendation from at least four Supreme Court justices. They also say at least one inmate on the list has more than one felony conviction. They ask the court to bar Newsom and the corrections department from acting on the announcement. Newsom's office referred Courthouse News to his Nov. 5 statement citing past leaders who commuted death sentences. The allegations have not been adjudicated.
Why it matters
The suit challenges whether a governor's clemency power allows mass commutations without the notice and review procedures the plaintiffs say are required. The allegations are unproven and the court has not ruled.
These are unproven claims, and everyone named is presumed innocent unless proven guilty. Researched with AI assistance from the sources listed here and reviewed under our methodology.
Dont Comply